Rusty Bucket Menu Prices

The Rusty Bucket is an American diner with endless food options, ranging from deli sandwiches, pastas, pizza, burgers, etc. you name it they have it.

People like to go here for the family style setting, the casual eating, and the friendliness of all staff and customers.

Rusty Bucket Menu

Deep-Fried PicklesBatter-dipped spears with ranch dressing for dippin’$7.99
Spinach Con QuesoA blend of spinach, white wine and cheeses, served piping hot with tortilla chips$7.99
Bucket BitesMini burgers on potato buns with grilled onion, yellow cheddar cheese and topped with pickle chips$8.49
Pork Potstickerspan-seared, with sweet chili & Ponzu sauces$8.59
MusselsFresh mussels sautéed in white wine, shallots, roasted tomatoes finished with garlic butter and served over our house made focaccia bread$8.99
Chicken FingersHand dipped, served with BBQ or honey mustard sauce$8.99
Bucket O’ ShrimpThe Bucket’s peel n’ eat shrimp one half pound in spicy Old Bay seasoning, served chilled with a fresh lemon wedge$10.49
HummusSomething light to start. served w/ grilled pita, marinated tomato & cucumber salad and side of tzatziki sauce$8.79
Double Stacked QuesadillaTwice as nice. blackened chicken, pepperjack and cheddar cheese, folded with black bean & corn salsa and served with sour cream, fresh guacamole and salsa on the side$10.29
Fresh Salads
Wedge of IcebergTopped with tomato, bacon, chopped egg and your choice of dressing$4.79
Double Nickel SaladYour neighborhood favorite! mixed greens topped with our special dressing, chopped bacon bits, bleu cheese crumbles, tomatoes and red onion$4.99
Double-Double Nickel Chicken Salad$11.79
Thai Steak SaladTeriyaki marinated grilled beef tenderloin, crisp greens, udon noodles, mixed Asian vegetables, pineapple and grilled bok choy all tossed in a soy ginger vinaigrette and topped with candied peanuts a$13.99
Blackened Salmon SaladBaby spinach, mixed greens with fresh strawberries, candied pecans, sliced red onion & bleu cheese crumbles tossed in a honey vinaigrette dressing$13.49
Caesar SaladCrisp romaine lettuce, crispy kale, house made sourdough croutons tossed in a creamy parmesan dressing add chicken $11.49, salmon $12.49$4.99
BBQ Chopped Chicken SaladMixed greens, tender pulled oven roasted chicken breast, tortilla strips, corn, pepperjack cheese, black beans & tomatoes tossed in cilantro ranch dressing & drizzled w/ BBQ sauce$11.79
Crock of soup
Texas Sirloin Chili$4.99
French Onion SoupSoup of the day$4.99
Rusty Bucket Wings
Rusty Bucket WingsThe fan favorite! all served with crisp celery sticks and bleu cheese dressing. Mild-Tamarind bbq, medium-sweet chili, joe's regular, chipotle, hot-sriracha, habanero$9.99 - $18.99
Served with a pickle and crispy, seasoned fries
Chicken Finger BLTTopped with bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo$9.29
Turkey ClubSliced turkey piled high and topped with tomato, lettuce, bacon, sliced cheddar cheese & mayo on Texas toast$8.99
Buffalo Chicken Sandwichpanko crusted chicken breast slathered in Joe’s regular sauce, topped w/ crumbled blue cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato & mayo$9.39
Philly CheesesteakShaved prime rib, red & green peppers, mushrooms, onions, provolone cheese and Philly sauce$9.49
Italian TorpedoGrilled Italian sausage topped with cappicola ham, salami, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, pepperoncinis & Italian dressing$8.99
Asian Tuna WrapA light and fresh option. soy marinated Yellow Fin tuna w/ wasabi mayo, sweet rice, marinated bean sprouts, peppers, cucumber, red onion & carrots w/ Ponzu sauce for dipping$10.49
The ReubenNew York deli-style with 1/2 lb. of corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and 1000 island dressing on grilled rye bread$9.49
Rusty Bucket Chili DogsTwo jumbo grilled hot dogs served on toasted buns w/ Dijon mustard, diced onion & topped with our sirloin chili, shredded cheddar cheese & served w/ our homemade chili pepper relish$8.49
CodwichBeer-battered Atlantic cod w/ tartar sauce, lettuce, American cheese, tomato, onion and cole slaw$9.79
Main Plates
MeatloafMade fresh daily, stacked atop our mashers and covered with BBQ gravy and onion rings. Served with green beans and oven roasted carrots$11.49
Backyard BBQ RibsLightly smoked Memphis-style ribs slathered with our Bucket BBQ sauce and served with french fries & cole slaw$13.99 - $20.99
Fish ’n ChipsPlenty of beer-battered coldwater Atlantic cod, french fries and cole slaw$13.49
Macaroni ’n CheeseA comfort food favorite. Swiss and American cheeses with elbow macaroni. topped with panko bread crumbs and oven-baked until golden brown. Served with garlic cheese bread$8.99
Pan-Seared SalmonHand-cut filet seasoned with a soy glaze, served with sticky rice and stir-fried vegetables$15.39
Chicken ParmesanSeasoned panko crusted chicken breast topped with marinara sauce, provolone cheese & served with pasta alfredo, served with garlic cheese bread$13.69
Parmesan Crusted TilapiaServed with skillet beans, sour cream mashers and roasted garlic cream sauce$13.99
Tavern Steak and Ale18 oz. Porterhouse seasoned and cast iron seared, served with Bucket fries and garlic sautéed mushrooms. Add a pint of your favorite Bucket draft 19.99$17.99
Pesto Chicken PastaSpaghetti sauteed with garlic, white wine, olive oil, fresh baby spinach, mushrooms and oven roasted tomatoes. topped with a pesto marinated grilled chicken breast & served with garlic cheese bread$13.49
Roasted ChickenPan-roasted boneless chicken breast served with sautéed garlic spinach, sour cream mashers and skillet gravy$12.99
All burgers served with crispy, seasoned fries. whole wheat bun available upon request
Rusty Bucket BurgerLettuce, tomato, onion, sweet pickle relish, mayo and American cheese$9.79
Burger BluesTake a burger— add bleu cheese, mayo, onion, lettuce, tomato, sweet pickle relish and pickle$9.99
Elvis Velveeta BurgerDripping with Velveeta cheese, grilled onion, lettuce, tomatoes, sweet pickle relish and mayo$9.99
Patty MeltA diner classic with grilled onion, 1000 island dressing and Swiss on rye$10.29
Gary’s Belly BusterFried egg, mayo & American cheese$9.99
Double Bacon Cheddar BurgerFor the bacon lover in you!! our ground bacon & beef burger topped w/ caramelized onion, cheddar cheese and more bacon w/ lettuce, tomato & roasted garlic aioli$10.29
Veggie BurgerSlightly spicy, crispy black bean burger with provolone cheese, roasted red pepper relish, romaine hearts and a lemon basil aioli$9.79
California Turkey BurgerWhole wheat bun with Swiss cheese and fresh avocado mayo served on the side$9.49
Artisan hand tossed 12 pies. Additional toppings: meats 1.50 each italian sausage, bacon Pepperoni, cappicola. Cheeses 1.50 each feta, blue cheese Fresh mozzarella, cheddar. Veggies 1.25 each green olives, jalapeños Banana peppers, red onions, spinach, ro
Pepperoni & Peppers;oads of mozzarella, provolone, pepperoni and fresh banana peppers$11.49
The Big SicilianPepperoni, Italian sausage and cappicola with mozzarella, provolone, peppers & red onions$13.49
Pizza PestoFresh pesto, roasted tomatoes, provolone & fresh mozzarella$10.99
MargheritaTender roasted tomatoes, garlic, fresh mozzarella & basil$10.99
VeggieRoasted tomatoes, mozzarella, provolone, mushrooms, bell peppers, red onion, banana peppers, green olives & spinach$11.49
Build your own PizzaCheese Pizza$9.99
Choose 3 Sides for $7.79
Tomato Cucumber Salad
Sautéed Garlic Spinach
Cottage Cheese
Sticky Rice
French Fries
Cole Slaw
Roasted Carrots
Broccoli Florets
Skillet Beans
Apple Sauce
Fresh Fruit Cup
Triple Chocolate CakeOoey-Gooey!!! homemade chocolate cake topped w/ Edy’s vanilla bean ice cream & caramel sauce$5.29
Sticky Bun Bread PuddingBaked custard & cinnamon bread topped with caramel and candied pecans, served with Edy’s vanilla bean ice cream$5.29
Cookies & CreamA chocolate chip cookie topped with Edy’s vanilla ice cream, caramel & chocolate sauces, pecans and whipped cream$4.99
Kid's Menu
Served with a choice of drink & side dish
Kid’s Hot DogAll-beef hot dog$4.95
Kid Fish ’n ChipsJust like it sounds$4.95
PB & J$3.95
Kid’s BurgerWith or without cheese$4.95
Chicken FingersWith your choice of BBQ or honey mustard sauce$4.95
Grilled CheeseOn white bread with American cheese$4.95
Mac ’n CheeseMade just for kids$4.95

About Rusty Bucket

The Rusty Bucket was found by Gary Callicoat in Columbus, Ohio in 2002. He was in the food industry since he was 15, but didn’t own a restaurant until this one when he was 37 years old.

They have 23 restaurants in Ohio, Indiana, Michigan, North Carolina and Florida with the majority in Ohio. They have received two “VIBE Vista” awards both in 2017 and them being: “Best Overall” and “Best Spirits.”

Rusty Bucket Review

The Rusty Bucket is an upscale, yet very casual dining room experience with you as the main show. They have the place set up with seats in the middle and booth on the edges with a good flow of the room.

The food is made with quality and freshness in mind, they cook everything from scratch and still does it as quick as possible to keep you happy.

A lot of customers recommend the Philly Cheesesteak, the fish tacos, and the spaghetti & meatballs these are all the hits among reviewers and patrons alike.

The service can be a bit slow, but it all depends when you go and if you call ahead or not. Most say the cover service is wonderful and the servers are very nice and efficient, but there have been a few instances of a lousy waiter/waitress.

Leave a Comment