Papa’s Pizza Menu Prices

Papa’s Tomato Pies is a pizza restaurant that serves classic Italian cuisine. It is known as the oldest family-owned and longest continuously operating pizza place in the United States.

Customers always return to this historic pizza place for the nostalgia and wide variety of pizzas (in which they call tomato pies) and specialty pies they offer, all at an affordable price.

Papa’s Pizza Menu

pizzas lasagna baked chicken, pasta soups a full salad bar
Cheese$6.99 - $11.99
1 Topping$7.99 - $12.99
2 Toppings$8.99 - $13.99
3 Toppings$9.99 - $14.99
Extra Toppings$0.75 - $1.50
Toppingspepperoni, beef, sausage, ham, chicken, steak, mushrooms, onions, bell and banana peppers, black olives, fresh tomatoes, jalapenos artichoke, spinach, pineapple garlic anchovies, feta cheese
Specialty Pizzas
Papa Supremepepperoni, beef sausage, onions, mushrooms, and bell peppers$10.99 - $16.99
Meat Supremepepperoni, beef, sausage and ham$10.99 - $16.99
Veggie Suprememushrooms, onions, bell peppers, black olives, and tomatoes$10.99 - $16.99
White Spinachfresh spinach, feta cheese, onions, black olives, and tomatoes$10.99 - $16.99
BBQ Chickengrilled chicken smothered with our tangy BBQ sauce$10.99 - $16.99
Steak Supremephilly steak, grilled onions, and mushrooms$10.99 - $16.99
Hawaiian Delightpineapple and ham$10.99 - $16.99
Hawaiian Chickenpineapple and chicken$10.99 - $16.99
Hot and Spicychicken, jalapenos, onions and bell peppers$10.99 - $16.99
all pasta dishes come with 2 pieces of garlic bread and a side salad with dressing of your choice
Spaghetti and Meatballs$5.99
Chicken Alfredo$5.99
Spinach Alfredo$5.99
Pasta Delight$5.99
Italian turnover made of pizza dough and stuffed with cheese or toppings of your choice of served with our zesty marinara sauce build your own cheese $0.60 each topping, extra marinara $0.25
Three Cheesemozzarella, cheddar and feta cheeses$5.99
Supremepepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms and bell peppers$5.99
Meatpepperoni, sausage and ham$5.99
Veggiemushrooms, onions, bell peppers, black olives and tomatoes$5.99
Hawaiianpineapple and ham$5.99
Grilled Chicken, BBQ Chicken, Meatball
all subs may be dressed with lettuce, tomatoes and are toasted upon request at no extra charge
Philly Steak N Cheese$3.99 - $5.99
Grilled Chicken$3.99 - $5.99
Ham N Cheese$3.99 - $5.99
BBQ Chicken$3.99 - $5.99
Meatball$3.99 - $5.99
Cheese Burger Sub$3.99 - $5.99
Pizza Supremepepperoni, sausage, onions and mushrooms$3.99 - $5.99
Italian Comboham n pepperoni$3.99 - $5.99
Clubham, turkey and pepperoni$3.99 - $5.99
Veggie Delightgrilled mushrooms, onions and bell peppers$3.99 - $5.99
Eggplantgrilled eggplant, ground beef and feta cheese$3.99 - $5.99
all salads comes with dressings of your choice. Choose from ranch blue cheese, Italian, French or 2000 Island
Greekfresh salad with bell and banana peppers black olives feta cheese dressed with extra virgin olive oil and vinegar$4.99
Cheffresh garden salad topped with pepperoni$4.99
Grilled Chickenfresh salad topped with our specially season grilled chicken$4.99
Side Orders
Mozzarella Sticks$3.99
Jalpeno Poppers$3.99
Chicken Nuggets$2.99
Buffalo Wings (10) Mild or Spicy$5.99
Garlic Bread$0.50
Lay's Potato Chips$0.69

About Papa’s Pizza

This restaurant was established in 1912 by Giuseppe “Joe” Papa and Adalene Papa in Trenton, NJ. To this day, it is still run by the family.

Papa’s Tomato Pies has only one operating location in NJ. They have been awarded the Munchmobile Pizza Patrol Award of Excellence in 2010. 

Papa’s Pizza Review

This restaurant has a very classic, cosy, and family-friendly ambience. It is decorated with white walls, colored glass lamps, and tables separated into booths and single tables.

Their food is absolutely delicious. Each dish is carefully cooked using traditional recipes passed along in the family for many years.

A must try is their unique Mustard Pie which is a local favourite and their famous tomato pies. They also serve a variety of soups, sandwiches, pasta, and seafood specialties.

Serving and waiting time may take 10-20 minutes. Service is excellent with their friendly and very polite servers who are always smiling.

Leave a Comment